thumbs down for india’s id cards
Last Updated : GMT 05:17:37
Emiratesvoice, emirates voice
Emiratesvoice, emirates voice
Last Updated : GMT 05:17:37
Emiratesvoice, emirates voice

Thumbs down for India’s ID cards

Emiratesvoice, emirates voice

Emiratesvoice, emirates voice Thumbs down for India’s ID cards

An Indian visitor gives a thumb impression
New Delhi - Arab Today

When Ravi Mundoli went to renew his driving licence in Chennai, an official notice informed him that he could not do so without an Aadhaar card.
More than 900 million people have been enrolled in the Indian government’s Aadhaar programme — a biometric system with a unique 12-digit number, designed to make it easier for Indians to prove their identity and register for services.
The Aadhaar (foundation) system captures fingerprints and iris scans, and is already the world’s largest biometric database. Any resident of India, regardless of nationality, can apply for an Aadhaar card free of charge.
But in October 2015, India’s supreme court instructed the government not to make Aadhaar a compulsory pre-requisite to access any state services.
Which is why the traffic bureau notice surprised Mr Mundoli, a software entrepreneur. As it turned out, the notice was either poorly phrased or poorly implemented.
Mr Mundoli managed to renew his license in the end, but he had to queue up at eight counters, whereas with an Aadhaar card, he would have only needed to visit four.
"It feels like it is not-so-slowly creeping into every facet of life, mostly in a way which respects the letter of the supreme court judgement but not the spirit," Mr Mundoli said. "The machinery is now increasingly designed to be slow as molasses if you don’t have one."
The government has not said that every resident of India must have an Aadhaar card. But in violation of the court order, various ministries have either made Aadhaar compulsory for particular services or, as at the traffic bureau, made it difficult to access these services without Aadhaar.
The list of such instances is long and growing.
As of last Thursday, anyone booking train tickets online cannot do so without an Aadhaar number.
On Saturday, the government said that more than 100 million children who receive free school lunches — a scheme designed to persuade poor parents to send their children to school — will need Aadhaar cards to receive meals.
But on Tuesday, facing heavy criticism, the government retracted this particular order. However, the education ministry said that children would still need to be enrolled for Aadhaar, even if their meal benefits did not stop in the interim.
Children aged six to 14 who receive free textbooks and uniforms under India’s Right to Education Act will need to apply for their Aadhaar documentation by the end of June, while a nationwide pension scheme now requires its 25 million members to submit their Aadhaar details.
At least a dozen other social welfare, health and education schemes have also made it compulsory for applicants to produce their Aadhaar details.
Civil rights groups are concerned about the linking of Aadhaar to public services.
"It’s designed to cause civil death — the loss of all or almost all civil rights [of] a person," said Gopal Krishna of the Citizens Forum for Civil Liberties, who has long advocated against Aadhaar.
He argued that its extensive database can assist in the violation of a citizen’s right to privacy. Other civil rights groups have petitioned the supreme court, arguing that Aadhaar and its implementation are unconstitutional.
In October 2015, the court decided that it needed a five-judge bench to hear and rule upon these petitions. But due to the supreme court’s work backlog, there has been a delay in forming the bench, Dr Krishna said.
Consequently, no entity currently exists to acknowledge violations of the court order which ruled that Aadhaar should not become mandatory.
The Aadhaar programme collects sensitive personal information such as biometrics, contact details and date of birth, prompting fears of data privacy and data security.
But Rahul Matthan, a Bangalore-based partner at a law firm called Trilegal, who has consulted with government agencies, said Aadhaar’s data security is very robust.
Mr Matthan pointed out that millions of people in India lack a reliable form of identification, and that Aadhaar was a well-designed solution to this problem.
"Aadhaar itself in my view is not dangerous," he said. "But to avoid bringing in identity theft and other problems, it’s important for us to have a really solid privacy law also."
The government permits private firms — mobile telephony companies or insurance providers, for instance — to use Aadhaar to verify identity.
"So it’s possible for someone in the telecom company to know that this guy, with this Aadhaar number, is speaking on the phone for this many minutes," Mr Matthan said. "And that kind of information about you will exist in other databases of private companies also. Theoretically, it’s possible to build quite a large profile of a person with access to these databases. That’s the real risk. That’s what a privacy law should target."
As he had not seen the text of the orders that made Aadhaar compulsory for railway ticket bookings or other services, Mr Matthan said he was unwilling to comment on their legality.
"But in general, the supreme court order is there — you can’t make it mandatory," he said. "Any requirement to make it mandatory will, at some point, be set aside by virtue of that order."

Source: The National

Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

thumbs down for india’s id cards thumbs down for india’s id cards

 



Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

thumbs down for india’s id cards thumbs down for india’s id cards

 



GMT 05:14 2024 Wednesday ,07 February

Sophisticated Classic Dining Room Design Ideas

GMT 16:17 2018 Thursday ,30 August

Five Saudi women pilots granted GACA licences

GMT 05:06 2024 Tuesday ,06 February

New hunt for flight MH370 gets under way

GMT 13:00 2017 Wednesday ,23 August

Civilians among 30 dead in Yemen air raids

GMT 15:12 2011 Friday ,29 July

Pakistan observes air crash anniversary

GMT 04:23 2012 Friday ,30 March

Abdul Halim Hafez past revealed

GMT 08:44 2015 Wednesday ,25 February

Lubna emphasises generosity of UAE

GMT 11:15 2017 Monday ,10 July

Moroccan TV host is happy for her program

GMT 09:55 2017 Saturday ,15 July

China's late Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo cremated

GMT 14:43 2011 Sunday ,03 July

Zeina denies wearing head veil

GMT 05:12 2017 Friday ,21 July

6.7-magnitude quake kills two in Greece

GMT 16:03 2011 Saturday ,18 June

Fifi Abdo alive

GMT 19:02 2017 Thursday ,28 September

Merkel says France, Germany share 'wide agreement'

GMT 13:59 2017 Friday ,27 January

22 killed in rain-related accidents in Pakistan

GMT 20:09 2017 Monday ,23 January

Palestin's minister

GMT 09:16 2017 Wednesday ,13 December

Dalia Mustafa resumes filming “Red Sulfur”

GMT 14:12 2016 Monday ,12 December

China takes top honors as Marrakech festival wraps up

GMT 09:57 2017 Tuesday ,10 October

Latifa underlines success of her new album

GMT 10:58 2017 Wednesday ,06 September

Khalid reveals reason behind absence from singing
Emiratesvoice, emirates voice
 
 Emirates Voice Facebook,emirates voice facebook  Emirates Voice Twitter,emirates voice twitter Emirates Voice Rss,emirates voice rss  Emirates Voice Youtube,emirates voice youtube  Emirates Voice Youtube,emirates voice youtube

Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2021 ©

Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2021 ©

emiratesvoieen emiratesvoiceen emiratesvoiceen emiratesvoiceen
emiratesvoice emiratesvoice emiratesvoice
emiratesvoice
بناية النخيل - رأس النبع _ خلف السفارة الفرنسية _بيروت - لبنان
emiratesvoice, Emiratesvoice, Emiratesvoice